Kennedy, the Vietnam War, and Intelligence Failures

In the discussions over how the U.S. went to war in Iraq and the prospects for that conflict, the Vietnam War has been raised repeatedly. These discussions typically focus on the prospects in Iraq (e.g., "is it a quagmire?"), but rarely mentioned are the troubling details of how the decision to go to war in Vietnam was made. It is now generally conceded that Congressional authorization for President Johnson to pursue that war vigorously was granted in the wake of what we now know was an "intelligence failure" - the supposed second attack on U.S. naval vessels in the Gulf of Tonkin never happened. As in Iraq, there remain serious questions about how aggressively officials moved to use the mistaken reports without verifying them, in order to pursue desired policy goals. Also, it has long been known that the naval vessels in question were engaged in aggressive intelligence-gathering maneuvers, in support of OPLAN 34A, a program of covert attacks against North Vietnam.

What does this have to do with the assassination of President Kennedy?

For one thing, the authorization for the OPLAN 34A program is contained in NSAM 273, the first National Security Action Memorandum signed by President Johnson (on November 26, four short days after President Kennedy's murder, following an emergency meeting on Vietnam on the 24th). This NSAM was drafted the day before Kennedy's fateful motorcade ride in Dallas, but the draft version differs markedly in the scope of authorization for such a program, and in any case Kennedy never saw or signed it.

Beyond the above is the larger question of Kennedy's policies and plans in Vietnam. Here, serious gaps in the record have been filled in since the passage of the 1992 JFK Assassination Records Collection Act. The gaps have been filled in with more details on the plans for complete withdrawal from Vietnam which were drawn up in the spring of 1963, and initiated on October 11 with NSAM 263. This gave the order for an initial pullout of 1000 men before the end of 1963, an event which never occurred.

With the filling in of the record - why were these documents a state secret for 35 years? - the debate among historians has shifted.  No longer is the issue whether there was a plan to withdraw - the question has moved to whether it was "serious enough" to survive the change in reporting of the battlefield conditions which occurred in the wake of Kennedy's murder, from optimistic to pessimistic. Some historians, including David Kaiser (American Tragedy) and Howard Jones (Death of a Generation) now argue that Kennedy was determined to withdraw despite a change in conditions, joining Peter Dale Scott, John Newman, and no less than Robert McNamara. Many mainstream historians and others - including Noam Chomsky whose book Rethinking Camelot is largely a rebuttal of this view - maintain that Kennedy's assassination was not a factor in the progress toward war in Vietnam.

Just like the questions swirling around how the U.S. went to war in Iraq, the questions about Kennedy and Vietnam should not be lightly brushed aside.

For more information, see:

Exit Strategy, by James K. Galbraith. The son of John Kenneth Galbraith argues that Kennedy was committed to unconditional withdrawal from Vietnam.

Rethinking Camelot, by Noam Chomsky. Chomsky's book-length rebuttal of the withdrawal argument is available online.

The Kennedy Assassinationa and the Vietnam War, by Peter Dale Scott. Scott wrote about this long before anyone else.

JFK, Vietnam, and Oliver Stone, by Gary Aguilar. Dr. Aguilar highlights the vociferous attack on Stone for presenting this viewpoint on Kennedy Vietnam policy in the film JFK.

Kennedy and Vietnam, on www.maryferrell.org. The new Mary Ferrell Foundation website features this issue, including links to essays and declassified documents, video clips of Peter Dale Scott, and more.

-- Rex Bradford
-- Gary Aguilar

Comments

[Anthony Scotti]

Kudos on your Coast to Coast appearance. With all the books Dr. Savage, George Noory, Art Bell and their many guests publish, I would like to point out that the digital avenues of revenue for these books has been restrained and in some instances completely passed by - because of a lack of interest in publishing an 'e-book'. The future of reading is not e-books but interactive digital multimedia books
Now new technology delivers an interactive, hi-definition 'digital book' -a virtual book whose html pages need no scrolling, offers hyperlink interfacing, text , audio, video content, narration of the book in the author's voice and can even download to mp3 players.
If you are interested in capturing untapped revenue streams go to avbooks.com for a demonstration of what your book could be!
A. Scotti

P.S. Please keep up the good work

[Susan Quinintino]

you need to give better information about kennedy's policy toward the vietnam war!
please and thank you!!

[generic viagra]

What is the purpose of war?
The wars year after year, day by day kill many people. There should be a way we have more peace in El mundo. People live in a world very nice and we have to care.

[Nick Spirelis]

I just finished reading the book Trauma Room One and found it to be very convincing. I just had a question for Dr. Gary Aguilar, one of the book's contributers. He says that Dr. Charles A. Crenshaw admits to exaggerating his role in attempting to resuscitate JFK at Parkland Hospital in Dallas. My question is in what ways did he exaggerage his role there?

Thank you.

[New Jordans]

Subsequent time once you are feeling down, strive placing on a smile. There is an outstanding prospect you mood will adjust for the far better.

[R. Oringer]

The first task LBJ did on 11/23/63 was to sign an order reversing JFK's order to reduce troop levels in Vietnam.

[Air Jordan]

Beauty is indeed a good gift of God; but that the good may not think it a great good, God dispenses it even to the wicked. Do you agree?

[Generic Cialis]

Hola,
Ha hecho un trabajo muy bueno. Hay muchas personas en busca de eso ahora van a encontrar suficientes fuentes por tus consejos.
espera para obtener más consejos acerca de que

[ClubPenguinCheats]

People live in a world very nice and we have to care.

[アンカロン]

Wow, Great postNice work, I would like to read your blog every day Thanks

[tinnitus cure]

Incredible montag of images, as regular. Who wouldn't be commencing to obtain while in the mood for fall along with the amazing climate here these days?!Thanks as usually for that inspiration.

[Generic Cordarone]

Hola,Ha hecho un trabajo muy bueno. Hay muchas personas en busca de eso ahora van a encontrar suficientes fuentes por tus consejos.espera para obtener más consejos acerca de que

[Networking solutions]

There are may person searching about that now they will find enough resources by your post,

[Seo Services India]

Is est vere interesting, tristique eget nulla ipsum. Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet quaeris ultra victum et tuos contulit vester iste stipes. Sed facilisis mi in amicabiliter networks dedi!

[Generic Viagra]

I think you are right when you say this. Hats off man, what a superlative knowledge you have on this subject…hope to see more work of yours.

[Oakley Sunglasses Discount]

JFK's order to reduce troop levels in Vietnam.

[Coach Outlet Store Online]

I agree that some words that simply does not make sense, but hey, look at it this way ... at least your child learn more how the words before his time. I do not think it's a waste of money. If it was not a gift, I paid for it.

[cheap sunglasses]

Any advert that does not help people find things they want to buy amounts to money spent in vain by the advertiser and time lost (and sometimes mood soured) for the consumer.

[gucci wallets women]

Article very well liked

[Generic Drugs Exporter]

Azt akarta, hogy többet tudjon konkrét témákban, de nem sok websites segítene nekem, ki tájékoztatása rám, ahogy vártam. Ez maradt meg sok kérdést, de elolvasása után a cikk, kaptam választ minden kérdésemre. Túl jó haver!

[ray ban uk]

read the post ,I think it is very good.

or perhaps you will like to the
kaptam választ minden kérdésemre. Túl jó haver!

[Buy Geodon Online]

Sea Niza a visitar su blog una vez más, han pasado meses para mí. Así este artículo que he estado esperando por mucho tiempo con. Necesito este artículo completar esta tarea en el colegio, y tiene tema de Sam con su artículo. Gracias, la participación de grandes.

[Rhinocort 200MDI]

I '
m lieta questa pagina straordinaria carità, questa è una forma di materia che sostengo, ma vede day.We out 'era spesso sentito ultimamente di voler sul vostro sito web a destra subito dopoHey,
Great idea, I would like to read your post every day,

[Facebook Developers]

I have no words to express how useful your blog was to me in completing my job work successful. Thanks a lot.

[ray ban]

I recently came accross your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I dont know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading. Nice blog. I will keep visiting this blog very often.